12 Best Indestructible Dog Toys for Heavy Chewers in 2024

Published on
Fluent Woof is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.
two border collies playing with their indestructible blue wheel toy

Chew toys are great because they provide your pooch with hours of entertainment, help keep his teeth clean, and take care of that strong desire to chew on things, most importantly it keeps him from eating your furniture and shoes.

You don’t want to get your dog something that is not safe for him to chew on so we dug deep into the doggie toy box and found some of the best of the best with certain standards in mind. For example, we looked at the type of material, size of the toy, whether it floats or not, and how durable it is for puppies as well as adults. 

After evaluating more than 20 indestructible dog toys, I chose the “Kong Extreme Dog Toy” as my favorite because it will stand up to even the most destructive chewer and is guaranteed so you know the company believes in its products, and your pooch can spend hours trying to get the treats and peanut butter out of the middle.

But I understand you might have different needs, whether you’re looking for an indestructible dog toy for your puppy or a treat dispenser toy. That is why I prepared a shortlist of our favorite indestructible dog toys that address different styles & needs. 

Before we dive into the review section below, we’ll help to find out which type of chewer your dog is, we’ll guide you on which toys are super-dangerous for your pup, and which materials you should look for in order to pick an indestructible toy. 

In addition, we’ll explain what criteria you should use to make the best selection for your needs

Finally, we’ll answer some common questions from dog parents.

So let’s get started.

Choosing The Best Indestructible Dog Toys

mixed breed playing with his big ball

When considering a dog toy for your pup, you need to think about what he likes and doesn’t like. If your dog doesn’t like bacon, getting him a bacon-flavored rubber bone is not going to be worth the money because he probably will not even touch it.

What does your dog seem to like chewing on? Does he love your shoes? Get him some toys that look like shoes. If he seems to love squirrels, give him a squirrel toy to chew on. And since all dogs love treats, those chew toys that you can put treats inside are paw-sitively excellent. 

In this section, we are going to talk about what type of chewer your pup is, the key features to look for in an indestructible dog toy, and we will even look at some toys that are not indestructible.

First, What Kind of Chewer is Your Pooch?

The way to find out what type of chewer you have is to watch them while they play. Is your dog intent on destruction or just likes to tenderly teeth his toys? There are three kinds of chewers, which include:

Inhaler: This type of pooch will make any toy disappear in minutes. You toss him a ball and it is gone when you turn around. You have to be careful with the inhaler because he may ingest something that clogs him up or chokes him. Always watch this pup with anything you give him.

The Shredder: If you give your dog a toy and he tears it into a hundred little pieces, he may be a shredder. These pups are intent on destruction no matter what you give them, so you have to get them something really durable, so he does not swallow any small pieces he tears off his toys. 

Nibbler: Many little furbabies are nibblers but big dogs can be nibblers too. These pooches take their time and are really gentle with their toys. You do not usually have to worry about finding a destroyed toy, but you never know. You should always play it safe by getting your dog a durable toy that is as indestructible as possible. 

Materials & Toys That Are Far From Being Indestructible 

We have already established that no toy is truly indestructible. Anything can be conquered by a determined dog, after all. But there are some toys that should just be on the “never buy” list. Here are some that we think are not a good idea for any dog. 

Squeaker toys: Toys made with squeakers inside of them are a lot of fun for our furbabies but they are not the safest choice for extreme chewers and shredders. Those squeaky toys may be exciting for your dog but if left alone for just a little while, your dog could easily rip apart the toy and swallow that squeaker. This can be extremely dangerous as it can be a choking hazard or cause a life-threatening intestinal blockage

Plush or fleece toys: Any kind of plush or fleece toy like a stuffed animal or even those sold that are “safe for dogs” are not really safe. Maybe if you sit there and watch your pooch the entire time he is playing with it but don’t leave him alone with it because any dog can tear those things apart and eat the stuffing or the material it is made of. 

Latex and vinyl toys: Anything made of vinyl is not safe for your dog to be chewing on. In fact, it is not safe for kids or pets to be playing with at all. Vinyl is made of polyvinyl chloride (PVC) and the plasticisers used in making these toys contain dangerous chemicals like phthalates. These chemicals can cause long-term liver and kidney damage. 

While latex may be safer as far as toxicity goes, it is not safe enough to give to your dog. For one, it is not durable and your dog can rip it to shreds easily. Also, many dogs have latex allergies that can be fatal. It is better to be safe than sorry.

Toys that contain toxic chemicals: Many toys made in other countries besides the USA have toxic material in them. According to the ecocenter, about 45% of dog toys have detectable levels of hazardous materials in them and 48% have lead in them. Check out the ecocenter website for a complete list of pet products that contain chemicals that are dangerous to your pup.

Toys with bells: Dog toys with bells are just like those with squeakers in them. Your dog will find them extremely exciting but they can become a danger as soon as he gets that bell out of there. And that is your dog’s main goal, to get that bell out of there. 

Stuffed toys: Like plush or fleece toys, your dog can chew them apart within minutes and whatever happens to be inside them can end up inside your dog instead. It is best to avoid these toys altogether unless you are just going to sit there and watch him play the whole time. 

12 Rules Of Thumb When Buying an Indestructible Dog Toy

large breed is playing with his blue Kong toy

We love to see our furbabies play but we also want them to be safe so we have to make sure the toys we give them are as safe as possible. 

After all, they use their mouths to play with and carry them so you have to make sure the materials are safe and durable.

Another consideration is your pup’s age because puppies and older dogs have different needs. 

Other things to think about are the texture of the toy, whether you can wash it, how entertaining it is, whether it has a warranty, and whether it is made in the USA or not. 

Our Recommended Materials: There are several materials that are considered to be the safest and most durable for dog toys. These include rubber, thick ropes, and nylon:

  • Rubber: The safest material for dog toys is rubber. As long as it is made right, a rubber toy is almost indestructible for any dog. You will find a plethora of dog toys made of rubber that your dog will enjoy for a long, long time.
  • Thick rope material: Thick rope is okay if it is made very well and does not fray. You also do not want it to have any plastic or other materials that may come off and become a choking hazard. It is a good idea to keep your eye on your dog when he plays with it and check it after each playtime to make sure it is still safe. 
  • Nylon: Certain bones made of nylon are very paw-pular with pups and since they are safe and durable, pup parents are happy with them too. You can also find other toys made of strong nylon like balls, tug toys, and flying discs.
  • Fire Hose Material: Another durable material is fire hose material. Although it cannot beat plastic or rubber for its strength, it is gentler on your pup’s teeth. This material is in the middle of soft toys and almost indestructible toys, and they can also include squeakers.

Your Dog’s Age:  Puppies and geriatric dogs have totally different teeth so it only makes sense that you should consider your dog’s age when choosing toys. A puppy needs a softer material for when they are teething because although their new teeth are sharp, they are not as strong and can be damaged by chewing on a toy made for an older dog. In fact, rubber toys that can be frozen to help numb their gums and ease the pain are great for this.

A dog of average age can use the harder rubber and those who are shredders would be better off with a toy made of the extreme rubber toys. And geriatric dogs may need a toy made of material that is in between the two, a bit harder than a puppy toy but softer than the typical hard rubber toy. Toys made from fire hose material mentioned above are good for this age.

Texture: Have you ever wondered why they make dog toys in so many different textures? Well, different dogs like different textures. Some pups enjoy the rope-style toy while others may like the smooth soft rubber ball. The toys with nubs on them are good for your dog’s sensory needs and can also help with teething pain.

Safety Of The Toy: The best way to make sure the toy is safe is to buy from a reputable company and do not try to save money. Although no toy is truly indestructible, those made by brands with excellent reviews that have been making dog toys for many years are recommended. You do not want your pup being able to chew a toy to pieces, creating a choking hazard for him and the other furbabies. However, there are also many new companies coming up with indestructible dog toys as well. 

Size & Shape matters:  The size and shape of the dog toy is important too. The size has to be compatible with your dog. You do not want a small toy for a big dog or vice versa. Getting a toy that is too small can be dangerous for any dog so do not buy your Great Dane a ball for a Chihuahua just because it is on sale. Choosing the shape depends on your dog’s chewing habits and how you intend for them to play with it.

Durability: Obviously, you want any dog toy you buy for your dog to be durable. Dogs play with their toys by chewing on them. That is just a natural thing for them to do. After all, your dog cannot pick up a ball with his paws and toss it around. So make sure whatever you get is made of a durable material like rubber. 

Safety of Material: You always want to buy from a reputable source. Your dog’s health is worth a few extra dollars. 

Some of the toxic chemicals you may find in dog toys include PVC (polyvinyl chloride), phthalates, BPA (bisphenol A), lead, chromium, formaldehyde, cadmium, and bromine.

Type of Toy: Treat toys are excellent for all dogs. It keeps them busy, teaches them patience, and helps keep their mind sharp. Those treat dispensers that you put the peanut butter or treats inside are great.

But they also have the puzzle types that are made to be interactive so you can enjoy watching your pooch learn while he plays. 

Fetch toys such as balls or flying discs are fantastic as well as long as they are made of a durable material like rubber. Tug toys are okay for some dogs but make sure they are made of rubber instead of rope. 

Washability: Being able to toss your pooch’s toy into the washing machine after a day at the park is wonderful. Can you imagine all of the germs your dog’s toys end up with after being tossed in the dirt, dragged through mud, and walked on by other dogs at the dog park? Try to find a toy that you can throw in the washing machine or dishwasher and it will make things so much easier.

Entertainment: You have to think like a dog when buying a dog toy because you don’t want to bring home a boring toy. Something that may seem adorable and fun to you may not be interesting at all to your furbaby. Reading reviews like this one can help you with that. Figure out what your dog likes and try to find a durable toy to match. 

Also, you should decide whether you want the toy to be a pacifier for your pooch to play with when you are gone or one that you can take to the dog park or beach. One way to make your dog’s toys last longer is to rotate them so your pooch thinks he is getting a new toy every time you give him back one that you have “hidden” for a while.

Warranty:  If you are going to spend extra money to get that really cool toy that says it lasts forever, it should come with a warranty, right? Well, some of them do. If a company is confident enough to offer a good warranty, they must be selling a good product, right? This is not to say that all the expensive toys are good and inexpensive ones are bad. In fact, there are a lot of toys out there that only cost a few bucks that are more fun and safer than those you may spend triple that amount on. 

Made In The USA: Although some people may think this is not a big deal, we know that toys made in the USA usually have to pass some stringent standards. For example, they are not allowed to use toxic materials in their toys. But those that come from other countries do not have to follow the same rules. 

Our 2024 Top Best 12 Indestructible Dog Toys  

Pitbull is running with his rubber ring toy in his mouth

After reviewing more than 20 indestructible dog toys using the criteria mentioned above, we chose 12 that we think are the best & safest for your dog to play with: 

Kong Extreme Dog Toy 

  • Material: All-natural rubber
  • Floats: No
  • Warranty: Yes all Kong dog toys have a 60-day satisfaction guarantee
  • Puppies Friendly: Yes
  • Made in the USA: Yes
  • Best for: our overall top pick

If your dog is a shredder, you need this toy! The Kong Extreme Dog Toy is made of the toughest rubber for the ruff-est chewer. The patented extremely durable rubber formula means you can feel safe letting your pup chew on it for hours without worry.  And it is recommended by veterinarians, trainers, and dog parents all over the world.

The shape is important because it gives the toy an erratic bounce that your pooch will love chasing. He does not know whether it will go right or left, back or forth, but that satisfies his need to chase and play. You will love watching him chase his Kong all over the yard.

And you can stuff it with peanut butter, treats, or some other paw-some food to keep your pup busy for hours. Your dog will enjoy trying to lick every last bit out of the middle of the Kong. If you want to keep your furbaby busy for even longer, pop it in the freezer for a few hours.

The Kong comes in five sizes for all dogs from tiny Terriers to giant Great Danes. The small is three inches while the XX-large is six inches with a variety of sizes in between so it is perfect for your dog too. And it is top-rack dishwasher safe, so it is easy to clean!

What We Like:

  • Stands up to the most extreme chewers
  • You can even leave your pooch unsupervised with this toy
  • Made in the USA
  • Easy to clean with a bottle brush or dishwasher

What Dogs Love about it?

  • The Kong has an erratic bounce that all dogs love
  • Challenging enough to get the treats out so it will keep him busy for a while

What We Don’t like:

  • Some dogs have trouble fitting their tongue in the hole to get the treats out
  • The sizing runs smaller than stated

Nylabone Puppy Teething X Bone  

  • Material: Plastic
  • Floats: No
  • Guarantee: Yes for 30 days
  • Puppies Friendly: Yes
  • Made In The USA: Yes
  • Best for: Puppies

This puppy chew toy is flavored with beef so your pup will love chewing on it. However, it is for puppies and gentle chewers since it is a soft material. This is a teething puppy chew so putting it in the freezer for a while will help with teething pain as well.

The Nylabone Puppy Chew X Bone is designed with a different texture on each of the four sides of the X, so your pooch has a variety of nubs and ridges. This is great for massaging those sore puppy gums, keeping them entertained, and working their gums as they chew.

Although this toy is tough and can take a bit of ruff play from Fido, it is important to supervise because the material is not as durable as rubber toys. It is designed to be softer just for puppies. This makes the X toy a fantastic one for playing fetch with your pup.

Because this toy needs supervised play, tossing it around the backyard or dog park is great since you will be watching what your dog is doing at all times. Be sure to check it for wear and tear when you wash it using mild soap and hot water.

What We Like:

  • Formulated for puppies with softer material
  • Recommended by veterinarians
  • It has a 30-day warranty

What Dogs Love about it?

  • A fun fetch toy because it bounces erratically
  • The beef flavor keeps your pup interested
  • Nubs and grooves ease puppy teething pain

What We Don’t like:

  • It will not last with rough chewers
  • Only for dogs up to 25 pounds

GoughNuts Ring Dog Toy

  • Material: Natural rubber
  • Floats: Yes
  • Guarantee: Yes, if your dog chews down to the red ring, they will send you a new one
  • Puppies Friendly: Yes
  • Made in the USA: Yes
  • Best for: Large Breeds

These Goughnut toys are made with your pup’s safety in mind to keep your mind at ease. Give your pooch a Goughnut to play with and you will not have to worry about watching him like a hawk. The tough thick rubber is made to withstand heavy chewing.

But even the best-made toys are not indestructible so Goughnuts have a red inner ring to indicate when it is time for a new toy. If your dog is able to chew down to the red ring, the company will send you another one, no questions asked. Just send it back to them and they will send you a new one.

The Maxx Goughnut is made for dogs over 65 pounds so your Great Dane or Mastiff will be fine with it. Large dogs need toys too. The Maxx is 6.25 inches in diameter with a cross-section of 2.1 inches, so it is big enough for your tuff pup.

However, if you do happen to have a smaller pooch, they have you covered too. The small one is 3.75 inches in diameter with a 1.3-inch cross-section for pups up to 40 pounds and the original is five inches in diameter with a 1.75-inch cross-section for dogs 30 to 65 pounds.

What We Like:

  • Tested for up to 3200 PSI for the originals and 3,600 PSI for the black one
  • Approved by veterinarians
  • The safety inner core gives a sense of security

What Dogs Love about it?

  • Bounces back
  • Floats
  • Fun to chew

What We Don’t like:

  • The Maxx may not be big enough for dogs over 80 pounds
  • Some shredders may be able to chew through it quickly
  • A very high price for a simple rubber ring toy

West Paw Zogoflex Large Tux Tough Treat Dispensing

  • Material: Zogoflex
  • Floats: Yes
  • Guarantee: Yes for 30 days
  • Puppies Friendly: No
  • Made In The USA: Yes
  • Best for: Treat-Dispensing Chew Toy

This fun toy is great for putting large treats inside. Your pooch will love trying to get the hidden treats out of the middle.

It is best to keep an eye on your dog when he is playing with this treat toy, especially if he has the tendency to chew things up quickly. Although they come in two different sizes, you have to check the size chart to make sure it is the right size for your pup.

This is a fun toy for swimmers. You can take it to the lake or pool because it floats so your dog can run out in the water to get it. Even without treats inside, any water-loving pup will enjoy chasing it out into the water and bringing it back.

You can stuff the toy with peanut butter, dog food, applesauce, or whatever you like to give your dog. Then put it in the freezer for a while until it is hard, and he will chew on it for hours. And don’t worry about clean up because it is safe for the top rack of the dishwasher.

What We Like:

  • Comes in several different colors
  • Two sizes so you can get the right one for your dog
  • It is easy to clean

What Dogs Love about it?

  • Fun to get the treats out of
  • Floats in the water
  • Bounces erratically

What We Don’t like:

  • The price is a bit higher than the others
  • May not last long for shredders

KONG Classic Flyer Frisbee Dog Toy

  • Material: Natural rubber
  • Floats: No
  • Guarantee: Yes all Kong dog toys have a 60-day satisfaction guarantee
  • Puppies Friendly: Yes
  • Made In The USA: Yes 
  • Best for: Playing Frisbee

The Kong disc is the perfect size and shape for all disc-fetching games. The natural light rubber will not hurt your dog’s teeth or jaws when he catches it no matter how hard you throw it. It is flexible as well as durable so you can play without worrying.

This is a fetch toy so your pup will need to be supervised during play. It is not made to be a chew toy and although it is durable as a frisbee, it is not a durable chew toy. It is best to give your dog a chew toy instead of the disc when you are finished playing catch.

It comes in two sizes so you can play with any of your pups with this toy. The small is 7.5 inches in diameter for dogs up to 35 pounds and the large is nine inches in diameter for dogs that are 30 to 85 pounds.

Dogs love the flexible material so they can toss it around and fold it over in their mouth. You will have to learn how to toss it since it is heavier than a regular frisbee, but it is worth it. And once you figure it out, it will fly better than the real thing. 

What We Like: 

  • Does not hurt the pup’s mouth or teeth
  • Easy to throw
  • Washable on the top shelf of the dishwasher 

What Dogs Love about it?

  • The wider rim makes it easier for dogs to pick up
  • The flexibility means they can catch it in the air 

What We Don’t like:

  • It does not stand up to any kind of chewing
  • Dogs over 85 pounds cannot use it

Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball Tough Dog Toy

  • Material: Rubber
  • Floats: Yes
  • Guarantee: Yes
  • Puppies Friendly: Yes
  • Made In The USA: No 
  • Best for: Playing fetch

Chuckit is created especially for extreme dogs who love to fetch as well as chew, so you do not have to worry. It bounces, floats, and flies like a bird when you use it with the Chuckit! Ultra Dog Ball Launcher.

But you don’t have to use the launcher. You can toss the ball around the backyard without worrying about it flying over the fence or into the woods. The material is made to be durable as well as being floatable.

The high-bounce rubber with a thick core keeps your pooch safe even when playing ruff. And the high-contrast orange color means your dog can see it easier. And you can too, just in case it does happen to go in the woods.

It comes in four sizes for all dog breeds and ages. The medium is 2.5 inches, the large is three inches, the x-large is 3.5 inches, and the xx-large is four inches. And although it is supposed to stand up to heavy chewing, it is best to keep an eye on your pup when playing with any toy. 

What We Like: 

  • Recommended by dog trainers
  • The ball really flies when using the Chuckit! Launcher
  • The variety of sizes means it is good for all dogs
  • The price is great 

What Dogs Love about it

  • It floats so he can play in the water
  • Good chewiness for exercising teeth
  • Easy to see 

What We Don’t like:

  • It is not made in the USA

GoughNuts Tug Dog Toy  

  • Material: Natural rubber
  • Floats: Yes
  • Guarantee: Yes, lifetime guarantee
  • Puppies Friendly: No
  • Made In The USA: Yes 
  • Best for: Playing Tug 

This tug toy is made for tugging so it is strong and durable and as close to indestructible as you can get. Although it does not have the red core to let you know when to get rid of it, Goughnuts toys are all guaranteed for a lifetime. So, if you think it is getting chewed up, send it back.

It is not designed to be a chew toy, so it is best if you only let your pup play with the tug toy when you are with him. The figure-eight shape is made especially for you to hang onto one ring while your dog pulls on the other. That way your fingers are not in the danger zone.

The interactive play is fun for both of you as you get to bond more than if you were to just give your dog a bone or chew toy. The Maxx comes in a nine-inch medium for dogs between 30 and 70 pounds and the 11-inch large for dogs 60 to 120 pounds.

For water dogs, you don’t have to worry. You can play tug in the water too because this amazing toy floats. The TuG is probably one of the best tug toys on the market today. 

What We Like: 

  • Lifetime guarantee is perfect
  • The shape means you don’t have to worry about getting nipped
  • Your pooch will love this fun toy 

What Dogs Love about it?

  • The toy is chewy, so it does not hurt teeth
  • It floats so it won’t get lost in the water 

What We Don’t like:

  • The price is pretty high
  • Not good for puppies.

Planet Dog Orbee-Tuff Tough Dog Chew Toy 

  • Product Details:
  • Material: Durable plastic
  • Floats: Yes
  • Guarantee: Yes
  • Puppies Friendly: Yes
  • Made In The USA: Yes
  • Best for: Chew-Ball that Bounces

Want your dog to have minty breath? Get him one of these Planet Dog Orbee Balls with peppermint oil-infused in it. The flavor is delicious to them and you will be happy with his minty fresh breath. And the non-toxic squeaker is safe for dogs without any glues or adhesives.

The plastic is specially made to be durable and free of BPA, phthalates, and latex. This means that even if your dog does happen to swallow a small piece, they will not get sick from chemicals. But it is still important to keep an eye on your dog while he plays.

You can play fetch at the beach or lake too because this ball floats too. Your best fur-iend will be thrilled with the bounciness and you will love watching him chase it around the yard or park. And your pup will love the squeak.

Although this is a tuff toy, it is not indestructible, so you need to watch your pooch with it and check it once in a while for damage. If it starts to crack or come apart, it is time to replace it. And with the guarantee, you are covered for up to 45 days. 

What We Like: 

  • The minty-fresh breath is pawesome
  • Having a guarantee means they trust their product
  • It comes in bright colors so it will be easier to find 

What Dogs Love about it?

  • The amazing bounciness is impressive
  • The flavor and scent makes it a winner

What We Don’t like:

  • The plastic is not as durable as rubber

Mammoth Cotton blend 3 Knot Dog Rope Toy

  • Material: 100% natural cotton
  • Floats: No
  • Guarantee: Yes
  • Puppies Friendly: Yes
  • Made In The USA: No it is made in Mexico
  • Best for: Knot Rope Toy

All dogs love to play with rope toys and it is always fun for pet parents to play tug with them. Interactive play toys like the Mammoth Cottonblend 3-knot Dog Rope Toys are fantastic bonding toys for you both.

But if you get tired, sit back and watch your pooch toss it in the air, shake it like an animal, and even bury it in the dirt. If you have another pup, they can tug together for even more fun. This is a fur-fect photo opportunity for you too.

And this versatile toy comes in five sizes for any breed of dog. The mini is 10 inches for pups up to 15 pounds, small is 15 inches for dogs up to 30 pounds, medium is 20 inches for dogs up to 50 pounds, large is 25 inches for dogs up to 80 pounds and the x-large is 36 inches for those huge dogs over 80 pounds.

While the rope toy is great for interactive and supervised play, it is im-paw-tant to know that rope toys are not for chewing. If you cannot watch your dog while he plays, he should not be playing with this rope because it is possible for pieces of the rope to come off.

What We Like: 

  • The fibers floss your dog’s teeth
  • Great for pups of all sizes and ages
  • You can microwave it for sanitization

What Dogs Love about it?

  • Tug-of-war is fun and interactive
  • The rope has three knots for even better grip 

What We Don’t like:

  • The fibers may come off with too much use

Benebone Wishbone Tough Dog Chew Toy

  • Material: Nylon and real bacon
  • Floats: No
  • Guarantee: Yes satisfaction guaranteed
  • Puppies Friendly: No
  • Made In The USA: Yes
  • Best for: Chew-Toy

Your dog can easily pick up this ergonomically dog-friendly chew toy and he will love it because it has real bacon in it. The entire toy is infused with 100% bacon so your pup will enjoy chewing on it all day long.

The wishbone comes in four sizes from small to giant. The small is 5.3 inches for dogs under 30 pounds, the medium is seven inches for dogs under 60 pounds, the large is 8.3 inches for dogs under 90 pounds, and the giant is nine inches long for dogs between 90 and 120 pounds.

The durable bone is good for all types of chewers from the Nibbler to the Inhaler so you can feel safe letting him chew on it all the time. However, it is good to check all of your dog’s toys every day to make sure they are still safe.

The happiness guarantee means that you can return this bone at any time for any reason if you or your pooch are not happy with it. Even if it has been months since you got it, the happiness guarantee is endless.

What We Like: 

  • The price is right
  • Durability means you don’t have to worry
  • Guaranteed for as long as you have it

What Dogs Love about it?

  • They can pick it up easily since it is curved
  • The bacon flavor is way better than chewing on plain old rubber

What We Don’t like:

  • The bone is too hard for puppies and older dogs
  • Your dog will really try to eat it, so you have to check it often

Nylabone Dinosaur DuraChew Dental 

  • Material: Nylon
  • Floats: Yes
  • Guarantee: Yes guaranteed for 30 days
  • Puppies Friendly: Yes
  • Made In The USA: Yes
  • Best for: Dental Toy

Let your pooch chew on a dinosaur that tastes like chicken and he will be happy all day long. Not only is it durable, it is also good for cleaning teeth because of the nubs. Your dog will thank you because it massages his gums and controls plaque and tartar as well.

It comes in three dino types: T-Rex, Stegosaurus, and Brontosaurus. But your pup probably will not care which one you give him because they all taste good and feel pawesome on their gums.

The dental bonus is especially good for teething dogs like puppies since it massages the gums and relieves teething pain. Pop it in the freezer for a bit to make it even more soothing. Even older pups like this feature and you will like that his breath does not smell bad.

The durable nylon will last as long or longer than any other chew toy you have ever given to your pup. And they come in two different sizes. The small is perfect for dogs up to 25 pounds and the large is good for dogs between 20 and 50 pounds.

What We Like: 

  • Gets rid of doggy breath
  • Floats so it won’t get lost in the water
  • The price is great (best of the bunch) 

What Dogs Love about it?

  • It tastes like chicken
  • Massages the gums
  • Durable chewing power 

What We Don’t like:

  • Only comes in two sizes

Buck Bone Organics Split Elk Antler Dog Chews

  • Material: Natural elk antler
  • Floats: Yes
  • Guarantee: Yes for 30 days
  • Puppies Friendly: Yes
  • Made In The USA: Yes
  • Best for: All-Natural Chew

For the dog who loves nature, try the Buck Bone Split Elk Antler. This all-natural chew is perfect for dogs of any size and is made with 100% elk antler, which gives it a great combination of color, density, and weight.

The elk bone will keep your dog’s teeth clean and offer him vitamins as well as protein, calcium, zinc, manganese, and phosphorus. The split bone means your pup gets to the marrow right away so he can taste it as soon as he picks it up.

Even puppies that are teething will enjoy the split bone because it is not as hard as the whole elk antler. It is sanded down to make it smooth and safe for your pup and as long as you get the right size, your dog will love it.

Being 100% natural means you do not have to worry about preservatives or toxic materials. And your pooch will love the all-natural flavor and scent. Try the four-inch for your small dog up to 20 pounds, the medium five-inch for dogs 20 to 40 pounds, and a large six to seven inches for dogs over 40 pounds.

What We Like: 

  • All-natural organic
  • Great source of zinc, manganese, phosphorous, calcium, and protein
  • Good for teething pups too 

What Dogs Love about it?

  • The flavor and scent of the marrow is intoxicating
  • They can chew on it all-day

What We Don’t like:

  • May stain furniture or carpet
  • Can splinter or break

Common Questions from Dog Parents

German Shepherd holding a blue indestructible frisbee in her mouth

What is the most indestructible dog toy?

Kong Extreme has the reputation of being the most indestructible dog toy on the market. Kong has been making dog toys since 1976 so they know what they are doing. The Kong Extreme is made for pooches of all sizes and breeds and will stand up to even the toughest chewers.

What material can dogs not chew through?

Rubber is the best material for indestructible dog toys. The rubber is almost completely chew-proof, especially when it is thick.

Are Kong balls indestructible?

According to the Kong website, Kong rubber toys are not completely indestructible, but they are designed to last a long time and to be safe for all dogs.

Should I let my dog destroy toys?

The main reason you should not let your dog destroy his toys is because of safety. When any toy is torn up or chewed to bits, it becomes a choking hazard. This is never a good idea.

Are there any indestructible squeaky dog toys?

There are durable squeaky dog toys, but they are not indestructible. Just like any toy, nothing is indestructible, but squeaky toys are more susceptible to destruction than others. This may be because of the way they are made or because your dog tries so hard to get to that squeak. Either way, they are not as strong as other dog toys.

How do you make indestructible dog chew toys?

If you are really handy and do not mind buying all the best materials, you can make a strong rubber toy that is comparable to a Kong toy. However, Kong toys will always be stronger for some reason. Maybe they have a secret ingredient we do not know about.

Durable tug toys vs. dog balls: what’s the difference?

Dog balls are better for your pup if they are made of rubber that cannot be chewed up and as long as it is large enough to not be a choking hazard. Tug toys are good if they are made of rubber but not rope. The rope can be chewed apart and swallowed no matter what the material.

How can I make my dog toys last longer?

The best way to make your dog toys last longer is moderation and supervision. Rotate toys by taking them away for a while and giving your dog other toys. Being interactive does not hurt either. Use toys that encourage other activities besides chewing like the treat toys that allow your dog to concentrate on getting the treat rather than chewing.

Can dog toys be toxic?

Unfortunately, there have been many dog toys taken off the market for being toxic or dangerous. Most have come from China and are made by small companies. Some of the toxic chemicals you may find in dog toys include PVC (polyvinyl chloride), phthalates, BPA (bisphenol A), lead, chromium, formaldehyde, cadmium, and bromine. The best way to avoid this is to stick with a well-known and trusted name brand.

What about durable dog toys for puppies?

Kong and other reputable dog toy manufacturers make different toys for the different stages of your dog’s life. For example, Kong has puppy rubber for beginners, senior rubber for older pups, classic rubber for “normal” dogs, and extreme rubber for those power chewers.

Why do dogs chew on toys?

Chewing is normal for canines of all ages. Puppies do it when they are teething, and older dogs do it to keep their teeth strong. It is really just instinctive. But it can also be a sign of anxiety or boredom. If your pooch is home alone often, he may get bored or have separation anxiety.

At what age does a puppy stop chewing everything?

Puppies typically chew on things when they are teething from age 12 weeks until about six months. However, it could last longer in some dogs. Try giving your pup a teething toy that is made to be frozen because that can help ease the pain.

Do Dogs Grow Out of the Chewing Stage?

Although puppies slow down on their chewing behavior after their teething phase is over, all dogs of any age like to chew. It is part of their natural behavior, which is why chew toys are so paw-pular. Some breeds chew more than others like terriers and retrievers.

Can dog durable dog toys get washed?

Most dog toys can be washed but you have to read the label to be sure. Don’t worry if your pet chewed off the label or you threw away the packaging. Just Google it. Rubber, nylon, and plastic can usually be washed in the dishwasher, but you have to make sure before trying it. Rope toys and plushies can be washed in the washing machine usually. But again, read the label.

 Are indestructible dog toys worth the price?

That is like asking if your dog is worth the price. Your pooch is your best friend, your family, and you want them to live a healthy, happy, and safe life. Paying a few dollars more for a trusted name-brand toy is most definitely worth the price!

The Final Woof

brown dog laying next to his indestructible treat dispenser toy

When you are looking for the best indestructible dog toys, you have to be choosy because your pooch means the world to you.

It is important to make sure that any toy you give your furbaby is safe for them to play with, but it is even more important when your dog is a shredder or inhaler.

Keep in mind that the toy has to be made with non-toxic materials and should not have any kind of stuffing or materials your pup can choke on.

It is clear that the main winner of indestructible dog toys is the Kong Extreme Dog Toy. It will stand up to even the most destructive chewer and is guaranteed so you know the company believes in its products. The price is not bad and is worth every penny when you watch your pooch spend hours trying to get the treats and peanut butter out of the middle.

Photo of author
Patty Oelze is a freelance writer who is also in the process of getting her PhD in Psychology. She has been writing about dogs and other critters for about 10 years and has a plethora of animals at her home including several cats, some chipmunks, a dozen raccoons, two foxes, one coyote, and herds of deer. She and her husband have been living in the Missouri Ozarks for years where she enjoys taking care of wildlife, fishing, photography, boating, and of course, writing.

Leave a Comment